Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Yeah, that was Stupid ...

When it comes to running shoes and knowing the Heel-to-toe drop/offset I am pretty much like Dustin Hoffman in Rainman. Name the shoe and I can tell you the drop. It is an odd skill. Knowing this little tidbit about yours truly makes the story you are about to read that much more moronic.

"I get my Brooks shoes at K-Mart in Cincinnati"
First ... What is Heel-to-toe drop? Basically it is the difference (in millimeters) from the heel to the forefoot of your running shoe.  The lower the drop (0mm) the more minimal the shoe is considered. the theory is that a lower drop encourages a more natural forefoot to midfoot strike. If you want a very, very detailed description check out this post on the subject by Runblogger.

Pic Pirated w/o Permission from VeggieFueledRunner.com  (Thanks Google Images)

Okay, now that we are all experts on Heel-Toe offset, let us move on to how I made a rookie mistake and am now paying the price.

I usually run in 3 different shoes:

1) Brooks Pure Connect 2's (4mm drop) - Short Races, Tempo Runs, and Track:



2) Brooks Pure Flows 2's (4mm drop) -  Medium Long Runs to Long Runs and any race 13.1 or longer:



3)Brooks Launch (9.5mm drop) - Daily Trainer and Recovery Runs:



All three of these shoes are perfect for what I use them for and I love alternating between the 4mm Drop of the Pure Project Shoes and the 9.5mm Drop of the Launch. I feel it gives me a different strike angle and since I usually run a lot of miles I think this helps prevent over-use injuries. I know of zero studies to support this theory but I am going on 6-years of running using this method and have never had a serious running injury (yes, I just knocked on wood, we are good).

Now a few months ago I picked up the Brooks ST Racer 5's (12mm drop).  I decided to try these out because the Launch were supposedly being discontinued (Brooks has since announced they are not discontinuing the Launch - whew!) and, well, they looked cool:


And for some reason I never looked to see what was the Heel-to-toe drop?

I had these shoes sitting in my closet and last week I decided to give them a try. I wore them around the house and they were very light (8.6oz) and were a little stiffer then the Launch but I liked the way they felt. Then the next morning rolled around and I had a 14mi run with 9mi at Lactate Threshold on the schedule and I walked out the door wearing my new, cool looking ST Racer 5's.

Bad Idea #1: Wearing a style I have never worn before for a 14mi run w/9mi @LT pace.
Bad Idea #2: Not noticing that these shoes have a 12mm Heel-to-Toe drop.
Bad Idea #3: Not stopping the run after my calf's began to feel a tingling sensation.

Why happened?

If you have ever transitioned into a minimalist-type of shoe, whether it be the Brooks Pure Series, Newtons, Vibrams, etc ... you were surely warned that the transition needs to be done slowly. Start with short runs and gradually increase them over a long period of time. This is not a theory, it is an outright fact. It actually took me about a year until I was able to do the marathon distance in the Brooks Flows.

AND ... Apparently this rule also applies for transitioning in the other direction too? On Sunday night I pulled up the Brooks website and looked up the drop (12mm) of the Racer 5's and realized immediately the error of my ways. I think people just never go from low drop to high drop so I learned this lesson the hard way.

And I didn't even have the excuse of being drunk!


So, this was on Sunday morning. My left and right calf were inflamed by Sunday night and walking was difficult. The pain is more in the lower calf, upper achilles area (soleus maybe?) and the left is much worse then the right. I've been forced to skip all my scheduled swims/bikes/runs over the last two days due to the strain but was able to go to the track early this morning and do some slow 800m repeats.

I am hopefully to be back at full steam by the weekend and actually relived that this bone-headed mistake just caused a little strain and not a major injury. I am still going to run in the ST Racer 5's as they are really fast and responsive shoe but I will need to keep the runs much shorter as my legs get used to them.

What did we learn today?

Lesson #1 -  I am an idiot.
Lesson #2 -  Know the Heel-to-toe drop on your shoes.
Lesson #3 -  I am an idiot.

Do you know the Heel-to-toe drop in your shoes? Will you now go look it up?

Thanks for Reading,

Jeff

39 comments:

  1. i alternate between the flows and ST-5s pretty regularly. I keep short speed stuff to the ST-5s, and long runs to the flows. No problems here. My soleusi (plural?) must be tough as shit!

    ReplyDelete
  2. #'s 1 and 3 were known already so we really only learned #2......

    It is funny that you mention going in the other direction because nobody ever thinks about that since ALL THE RAGE was going to a more minimal shoe, which the article that showcased that no barefoot runner has ever won a marathon.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I got injured in 2011 (left knee meniscus strain). Post injury I was running in the New Balance 890 (8mm drop). Then when those shoes were almost worn out in Oct 2012, I bought the Brooks Pure Flows (4mm drop) and Newtons (2mm drop). I didn’t really notice much calf pain at all while running in them, I transitioned to them likely too quickly (over maybe 2 weeks or so) – I should have bought another pair of the New Balance 890s, since my old 890 pair were too worn out to wear again. Also, I likely ran in the 890 shoes too long, I probably should have bought another 890 pair in maybe August or so.

    And before even starting in with the Brooks and Newtons, my left knee was already giving me some problems, so what I believe happened is that by transitioning too quickly to Brooks and Newtons I compressed my left knee meniscus too much due to the higher impact forces from running in a minimal shoe. I likely should have continued to run in a more traditional cushioned shoe (maybe New Balance 890) and never gone minimal. Maybe I would have had problems even without going minimal, but I think the minimal shoes likely didn’t help. So while people seem to talk ad naseum about calf pain with going minimal, lurking in the background is meniscus compression due to higher impact forces (or this is what I think). So your plan of using different shoes for different things sounds good to me to avoid injuries.

    2 weeks ago I bought a pair of hokas, which I will likely run in for now. They feel like they have a lot of support and felt even better than the New Balance 890 when I tested them in the store.

    So it seems like I made 3 main mistakes that have contributed to my left knee pain coming back:
    -not replacing my New Balance 890 shoes early enough before they were worn out
    -transitioning to minimal shoes without having a brand new traditional running shoe to rotate in to transition with
    -trying minimal shoes at all with my recent injury history was likely a mistake

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. the minimalist shoes are not for every one and we need to be careful (as we both found out) when making drastic changes to our footwear.

      Hope it works out for you.

      Delete
  4. Thankfully you're now super skinny. Imagine how much more hurt you'd be if you were having lug around extra weight!

    You know I'm sort of kidding. You're not an idiot ...you just missed a beat is all. Glad it isn't serious. Here's to speedy recovery!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Welcome to my world and times it by 365 ;-)

    I have a pair of ST4 and I think I told you, they were used twice and I didnt like them. You already know my rotation is Cadence for short runs, Adrenaline for long runs. It works for me, as much as working for me can.

    Ok, so what is the Hoka drop? Like 510 MM? I seen go go dancers in shorter soles

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Depending on the Hoka model they are between 5-6mm. The Bondi's are a 5mm.

      Hoka really is a smart design. Whether intentional or by luck they designed a shoe with a ton of EVA that cushions the forefoot and midfoot. Most "maximist" shoes load up the cushioning in the heel which is designed to alleviate the pounding that heel strikers absorb. BUT the Hoka is actually a neutral shoe that works for midfoot and forefoot runners. I think a few other companies will start to follow this model of cushioning the front of the shoe.

      Delete
  6. random, but to Jason's comment above - Abebe Bikila won the 1960 olympic marathon in Rome barefoot. If the talent is there, people can win wearing anything or nothing.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Yeah that is a big jump from the 4'ish drop to a 12!! I am a BIG BIG fan of the 4mm drop shoe, PureFlows are my favs at the moment now that Saucony botched the Kinvara. I also have my "unproven" theory that switching off shoes gives your foot a variety of ways to land and puts different loads and stresses on the foot/leg reducing overuse injuries. I can't believe no one has looked into that burning research question!!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I did something similar. I was out of town and realized I had forgotten my shoes so I ran in an old pair of brooks I had in the car. I figured how much damage could I do and I felt like I would have been making an excuse if I didn't workout. I normally wear 3-4 mm drop shoes and these were 12. One run. My foot went numb (finished the workout anyhow) and when the feeling came back I had PF. That was December. I still have it. One stupid run. Oh, did I mention that I stopped wearing those because I got PF in them two years ago. I am clearly not the brightest duck in the pond either. Glad to know I keep good company!

    I hope it heals up quickly!!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Ahhhhh but you are the rainman, right? Rainman can name the drop not necessarily the repercussion of not wearing the right drops... Given that...
    KSwiss Tubes.... drop?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Kswiss blades are zero drop. Not 100% sure about the Tubes. I tried on a pair before and found them to be pretty step. And they were like 12oz. I just did an online search and could not find a number but my best guess is in the 12-14mm range.

      Delete
  10. hope this little issue doesn't hold you down too long!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I know the drop on a variety of shoes. Well, mostly just the minimal ones. Since they're almost all 4.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I prefer 0 drop, although 4mm works for me too. I use Saucony Type A5 racing flats and rotate in altra adams. What I really require is no arch. My flat feet hates arches.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Very interesting! Since going to 4 mm and zero drop shoes, I haven't looked back. They really are right for me. That said, my goal of getting to 100% zero drop may never happen...just seems that I am limited in how far I can go in them. So I wear the Connects on long runs and throw in various zero drops (including the Drift sans insole) on shorter runs. I probably do about 50/50 mileage between the two drop sizes.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I could have told you #1 and #3 without you having to go through this. I used to run in Brooks DYADs (12mm I think). After switching to Hokas and Kinvara (4mm), I can't run in anything steeper. Granted, I haven't tried something in between 4 and 12, but I tried the DYADs again and ended up having to do a 2mile walk of shame home after my ankles and skins were on fire.

    Check these babies out... I need them... http://blog.saucony.com/saucony-lab/product-corner/virrata-0mm-drop-with-cushioning/

    ReplyDelete
  15. I've gone through this test and fail scenario a few times myself. It has taken me about 2 years now to finally get to wear I can run in 4mm and not feel an residual effects after the run. Only problem is that I can't do anything over 9 miles yet without getting tiny sore spots on my shin or on my heel. Odd. I can still go back to my 35 mm drop asics with 10 lbs of gel though and still run ok.

    ReplyDelete
  16. great news it was not a worse injury!

    I think by accident I change my running style and strike over the past 3 years or so by training in Sauc Mirage and lately the Brooks PureFlow....I think it took awhile for my calfs to adapt to the new style with big injury a little over a year ago....but still love the Sauc Cortana for long distance...I think that one is 8mm? Those tank Asics Kayano with the huge chunks of plastic and 12mm drop did great for me when I was 240lbs!!!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hey I hope you are all healed up by now!! I have no idea of my drop? I know I made the mistake of reducing my drop and putting on a lot of mileage one time and ended up with a screwed up calf...

    ReplyDelete
  18. Jeff,

    Good to see someone advocating a gradual approach to the change to more minimal shoes (I see too many people try to jump straight into that 4mm or 0mm shoe and end up regretting it big time).

    As for your regression you've got an interesting habit there between the 4 mil and your 9.5 mil shoes for training. Although I personally train in the excel-33 (10 mil) and race in something 4 mil (currently the piranha sp3, but they're shot and discontinued so who knows what now).

    Hope the healing goes well.
    Jesse

    ReplyDelete
  19. Jeff,

    Good to see someone advocating a gradual approach to the change to more minimal shoes (I see too many people try to jump straight into that 4mm or 0mm shoe and end up regretting it big time).

    As for your regression you've got an interesting habit there between the 4 mil and your 9.5 mil shoes for training. Although I personally train in the excel-33 (10 mil) and race in something 4 mil (currently the piranha sp3, but they're shot and discontinued so who knows what now).

    Hope the healing goes well.
    Jesse

    ReplyDelete
  20. I'm not sure about minimal shoes, I've had so many injuries over the years that I'm now over-cautious about changing my shoes from Asics Gel Kayano, which are excellent, to anything else.

    http://chasethepotato.wordpress.com/

    ReplyDelete
  21. I've been dealing with foot pain for some time and yeah a change in position and repetitive striking more than you can handle and your body will let you know I'm still paying for it lol. I've heard runners buying up two to three pairs of shoes of the same so they can keep the change of foot strike to a minimum which is something all runners need to do in my opinion, the more change the more it will leverage your bones and muscles. Also a good set of posture exercises to help keep the body in alignment can really help in the long run, meaning years down the road. Good Luck!! Ever try barefoot running? Look into posture alignment like that pain free book, really great read and is a mind opener for sure. Happy running :)

    ~Randall

    ReplyDelete
  22. Really very informative and the way you presented your information attracts visitors to read more informative blogs from your website. So I kindly look forward to see next updates.

    Compression socks running

    ReplyDelete
  23. Great information! I have to admit, I know nothing about my shoe's heel-to-toe drop...but, I am limited in which shoes I can wear. I am flat-footed and tend to wear a motion control or stability shoe. They're not pretty and never come in cool colors, but they work for me!

    ReplyDelete

  24. Good collection of shoes and all of this shoes design are very nice.This is an excellent post and very insightful.You have done really very good site. Great work, great site.Your site offers valuable information and good looking.I am very impressed to watch your site.I hope that you can improve. Success you will wait the next day.
    3d wall panels
    glass mosaic tiles
    glass tiles
    glass and stone tile
    Interior wall panels
    3D wall decor
    Stone glass mosaic
    kitchen tile backsplashes



    ReplyDelete
  25. Rugby World Cup 2015 Live

    The Rugby World Cup 2015 is scheduled to be the eighth Rugby World Cup, the quadrennial rugby union world championship.

    The tournament will be hosted by England[nb 1] from 18 September to 31 October 2015. Twickenham Stadium in London will host the final.

    England was chosen to host the competition in July 2009, beating rival bids from Italy, Japan and South Africa. The competition's organisers, Rugby World Cup Limited, had recommended England to the International Rugby Board (IRB; now known as World Rugby.

    Of the 20 teams competing at the 2015 World Cup, 12 of them qualified by finishing in the top three places in their pools in the 2011 World Cup. The other eight teams qualified through regional competition. Of the 20 countries that competed in the previous World Cup in 2011, there was only one change – Uruguay replaced Russia.

    Rugby World Cup 2015 Live

    ReplyDelete
  26. 真愛旅舍視頻聊天室-live173影音視訊live秀
    真愛旅舍官網-live173影音live秀
    真愛旅舍官網-live173影音live秀
    影音視訊聊天室-真愛旅舍
    影音視訊聊天室-真愛旅舍
    小可愛視訊-真愛旅舍視頻聊天室
    ut聊天室視訊-真人裸聊秀場
    173免費視訊-視頻真人秀聊天室福利
    真愛旅舍官網
    真愛旅舍聊天室
    歐美成人做愛電影視頻視頻美女裸聊網站樂吧99多人聊天室激情同城約會國外視訊網站
    成人人妻視頻影院視頻美女全裸聊網站午夜視訊聊天網站最新女優視頻國外視訊聊天
    操我啦成人視頻免費多人視頻社區紅樓嗨吧聊天室快播黃色電影下載免費看a片免費國外視訊
    人妻露臉小姨子成人視頻喔喔98視頻聊天成人三色聊天室 成人貴族色情網小說一元視訊聊天
    成人午夜黃色視頻聊聊多人視頻社區台灣免費視頻裸聊室金瓶梅三級片電影一元視訊聊天交友

    ReplyDelete
  27. 真愛旅舍視頻聊天室
    真愛旅舍視頻
    真愛旅舍app
    85街官網-視頻啪啪免費聊天室
    免費視訊聊天室友-六間房被禁視頻
    網路交友聊天-美女秀聊天室破解版
    成人免費視訊聊天室-福利啪啪視頻吧
    小可愛視訊聊天室-裸聊直播間
    免費視訊-真愛旅舍 聊天室
    美女視訊影音-真愛旅舍聊天室破解
    成人黃色視頻免費的喔喔視頻社區同城交友找情人約炮網俺去擼色午夜色波霸影院免費視訊秀
    91成人視頻網56as視頻聊天網免費的裸聊qq日本美女床上三級片同性女女電影173免費視訊秀
    CL社區成人視頻天天聊娛樂視頻社區58色聊情人網日本女優寫真大全173免費視訊秀
    色狼集中營成人視頻聊室語音聊天室sm視頻網站你懂的女明星合成圖片黃照免費視訊聊天秀
    妞妞2015年成人視頻聊天室直播視頻qq視頻裸聊表演三級電影播放國外免費視訊 live 秀

    ReplyDelete
  28. 漾美眉視訊交友聊天室
    激情真人秀場聊天室
    真人秀場聊天室
    聊性聊天室
    一夜i情聊天室
    免費開放聊天室
    午夜聊天室推薦
    一對一性聊天室
    視頻直播聊天室
    夫妻秀聊天室
    網愛吧視頻網站真愛旅舍視頻聊天室qq群視頻直播夫妻大秀成人免費午夜劇場做愛影片
    真愛視頻聊天室真愛旅舍聊天室破解版裸聊直播間快播有聲黃色小說熟女色圖9999av 影片
    台灣真愛旅舍聊天室摳摳視頻秀293真人秀場午夜電影劇場日本動畫片成人伊莉影片區不能看
    真人裸聊網579免費裸聊裸體色女觀看免費色女人聊天室午夜性影院歐美avi免費線上看影片
    美女真人裸聊qq號真人裸聊qq號碼是多少同城免費視頻裸聊亞洲日韓色情電影go2vo免費影片

    ReplyDelete
  29. 台灣真愛旅舍聊天室
    夫妻視訊午夜聊天室
    女性開放聊天室
    成人免費視訊聊天室
    真愛旅舍app
    台灣色情視訊聊天
    台灣uu聊天室視頻破解
    網絡色情視頻聊天室直播
    台灣真人裸聊視訊app
    免費真人裸聊qq
    台灣一對一視頻聊天室同城午夜一夜情交友網站真人裸聊直播社區性感白絲網襪美女性愛影片
    俺去也成人視頻免費在線播放真人聊天視頻聊天室歐美性愛夜夜擼影院打飛專用專用網免費影片
    成人午夜色情視頻床友約炮網免費裸聊網站誘惑絲襪性感電影成年人快播影院hilive影片
    日本美女免費黃色視頻聊天室免費床友交友網真人視頻裸聊天室日本成人頻道杜蕾斯免費影片
    真人裸聊qq號碼在線真人聊天視頻跳舞69美女直播成人三級電影在線觀看伊利影片區

    ReplyDelete
  30. CrownQQ Agen DominoQQ BandarQ dan Domino99 Online Terbesar

    Yuk Buruan ikutan bermain di website CrownQQ
    Sekarang CROWNQQ Memiliki Game terbaru Dan Ternama loh...

    10 permainan :
    => Poker
    => Bandar Poker
    => Domino99
    => BandarQ
    => AduQ
    => Sakong
    => Capsa Susun
    => Bandar 66
    => Perang Baccarat
    => Perang Dadu

    Keunggulan bermain di CrownQQ :
    => Bonus Refferal 20%
    => Bonus Turn Over 0,5%
    => Minimal Depo 20.000
    => Minimal WD 20.000
    => 100% Member Asli
    => Pelayanan DP & WD 24 jam
    => Livechat Kami 24 Jam Online
    => Bisa Dimainkan Di Hp Android
    => Di Layani Dengan 5 Bank Terbaik
    => 1 User ID 10 Permainan Menarik
    => Menyediakan deposit Via Pulsa

    Link Resmi CrownQQ:
    - maincrownqq.com
    - maincrownqq.net
    - maincrownqq.org

    Info Lebih lanjut Kunjungi :
    Website : DominoQQ Online
    Daftar CrownQQ : Poker Online
    Info CrownQQ : Kontakk
    Linktree : Agen Poker Online

    WHATSAPP : +6287771354805
    Line : CS_CROWNQQ
    Facebook : CrownQQ Official
    Kemenangan CrownQQ : Agen BandarQ

    ReplyDelete